How to Choose: Cedar Shake vs Wood Shingle in NJ

Cedar shakes are hand-split or machine-split, producing a rough, textured surface with varied thickness (3/4 to 1-1/4 inches). Wood shingles are machine-sawn, creating a smooth, uniform appearance with consistent 3/8 to 1/2 inch thickness. On Essex County homes, shakes deliver a more rustic, artisan look while shingles appear more refined and formal.

The visual difference is significant from the street. Shakes create dramatic shadow lines and texture that complement craftsman, rustic, and mountain-lodge styles. Shingles suit colonial, cape cod, and traditional homes where a cleaner wood look is desired.

Cedar shakes' greater thickness provides better insulation value and wind resistance. In Essex County, where nor'easters can deliver sustained high winds, shakes are less likely to lift than thinner shingles. However, shakes' rough texture traps more moisture and debris, encouraging moss growth in our humid climate.

Wood shingles shed water more efficiently due to their smooth surface, which can extend life in NJ's wet climate. They also dry faster after rain, reducing the sustained moisture contact that causes wood decay. For north-facing or heavily shaded roofs in Essex County, shingles may outlast shakes.

Choose cedar shakes for bold rustic aesthetics, maximum thickness and wind resistance, and homes with good sun exposure for drying. Choose wood shingles for a refined traditional look, faster water shedding in wet climates, and easier installation and repair.

Both require annual maintenance in Essex County's climate. Budget $300-$600 per year for professional cleaning and treatment regardless of which product you choose. Both carry similar fire ratings unless pressure-treated.